
How to Choose Macaron Flavours for a Mixed Group
Macarons can make a dessert table feel colourful and considered without requiring every guest to choose the same dessert. They work for birthdays, showers, weddings, office gatherings, holiday celebrations, gifts, and smaller get-togethers. The challenge is deciding which flavours will suit a group with different preferences.
At Bake Sale, our current macaron collection includes assorted six-piece and twelve-piece options, a pick-your-own twelve-piece option, and a macaron tower. Our website also lists thirteen macaron flavours, although the exact selection available for your order should be confirmed at the time of purchase. Explore the current macaron collection before making a final plan. (bakesaletoronto.com)
Start with the group, not just the flavour list
Before choosing flavours, think about how the macarons will be served. A mixed group might include children and adults, guests who prefer familiar flavours, people drawn to fruit-forward desserts, and guests who enjoy richer chocolate or nut-based choices. You do not need to predict every preference. Instead, aim for a selection with a few different flavour styles.
A useful starting point is to divide the options into broad categories:
- **Familiar and gentle:** vanilla bean, birthday, and strawberry.
- **Chocolate and dessert-inspired:** chocolate, red velvet, salted caramel, and tiramisu.
- **Bright or fruit-forward:** lemon and strawberry.
- **Distinctive or more specific:** bubble gum, cotton candy, coconut, hazelnut, and pistachio.
These groupings are planning suggestions based on the current flavour descriptions, not guarantees about what every guest will prefer. Bake Sale’s product page describes the fillings and finishes for the listed flavours, including vanilla bean cream, lemon meringue filling, strawberry buttercream, chocolate buttercream, salted caramel cream, hazelnut cream, and pistachio cream. (bakesaletoronto.com)
For a group you know less well, consider including several familiar choices before adding more distinctive flavours. For a birthday or themed event, a playful flavour such as birthday, bubble gum, or cotton candy may help match the mood. For a more formal dessert table, a combination such as vanilla bean, chocolate, lemon, salted caramel, and pistachio may create variety without making the display feel random.
Build variety into the order
Once you understand the group, choose how much variety you actually need. An assortment is convenient when you want the bakery to provide a selection of current flavours. A pick-your-own box gives you more control when you already know what the guests enjoy or when the celebration has a clear colour or flavour direction.
For example, a twelve-piece box could be planned in three broad groups:
- **A reliable base:** choose familiar flavours such as vanilla bean, chocolate, birthday, or strawberry.
- **A fresh contrast:** add lemon or another fruit-led option for guests who prefer a brighter bite.
- **A signature choice:** include salted caramel, pistachio, hazelnut, tiramisu, or another flavour that reflects the occasion.
The exact number of each flavour depends on the event and the current ordering options. Do not assume that every listed flavour can be combined in any quantity or that every flavour will be available on a particular date. Confirm the current choices with Bake Sale before checkout if the mix is important to your event.
For a larger gathering, you may also want to repeat the most broadly appealing flavours rather than selecting one of everything. Repetition can make the table easier to understand and helps ensure that guests who arrive later still have familiar choices. For a smaller gathering, an assortment may be enough to let guests sample different flavours without creating too much leftover dessert.
Bake Sale currently lists six macarons, twelve macarons, a pick-twelve option, and a macaron tower. Product formats and pricing can change, so use the live collection page for the current details rather than planning from an older menu or screenshot. (bakesaletoronto.com)
Check ingredient questions before ordering
Macarons may be described as gluten-free on Bake Sale’s FAQ, but the bakery also states that it is not a nut-free bakery and cannot guarantee products are free from nuts or other allergens. If anyone in the group has an allergy, intolerance, or ingredient concern, do not treat a flavour name as enough information. Ask the bakery about the specific product and current ingredients before placing the order.
This is especially important when considering flavours such as hazelnut or pistachio, but ingredient questions should not be limited to those names. Shared preparation areas, fillings, toppings, and recipe changes are matters that need to be confirmed directly for the order you are considering. Bake Sale’s public FAQ advises customers to speak with staff about ingredients for a specific product. (bakesaletoronto.com)
If you are serving macarons at a workplace, school-related gathering, shower, or event venue, keep the confirmed product information available to the person setting out the dessert. If you cannot confirm whether a product suits a guest’s dietary or allergy needs, choose another arrangement for that guest rather than making an assumption.
Plan pickup, delivery, and serving details
Macarons are small, but the order still benefits from a practical handoff plan. Write down the event date, the preferred format, the flavour preferences, the number of guests, and whether you need pickup or delivery. Bake Sale’s website lists its location at 5230 Dundas Street West in Toronto, along with online ordering for pickup or delivery. The current collection page also states that orders placed by 7 p.m. may be eligible for next-day pickup or delivery, but availability and the details for your order should be confirmed before relying on that timing. (bakesaletoronto.com)
If you choose delivery, double-check the address, unit number, buzzer information, recipient phone number, and access instructions. Bake Sale’s published policy explains that address or date changes require advance notice and that delivery timing can be affected by circumstances such as weather, traffic, holidays, or road conditions. Specific delivery times cannot be guaranteed. (bakesaletoronto.com)
For serving, keep the macarons in their packaging until you are ready to arrange them. Bake Sale’s product information says macarons should be refrigerated and taken out 30 minutes before enjoying. If you plan to serve them another day, the product page advises storing them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to four days. Follow the current product guidance and confirm any questions with the bakery. (bakesaletoronto.com)
A simple final checklist can help:
- Confirm the guest count and serving style.
- Choose assorted or pick-your-own macarons.
- Include familiar, bright, and distinctive flavour categories.
- Ask ingredient and allergen questions before ordering.
- Confirm the current flavours, format, availability, and order details.
- Review pickup or delivery information before checkout.
- Plan refrigeration and serving time.
At Bake Sale, we offer macarons alongside cakes, cupcakes, cookies, custom sugar cookies, cake pops, squares, scones, gifts, and ice cream cakes. Explore our cakes, cupcakes, cookies, cake pops, squares, scones, gifts, and celebration options, or contact us for help choosing the right fit and confirming pickup or delivery details.
Sources
-
Macarons – Bake Sale Toronto — Bake Sale Toronto
Current macaron collection formats, listed assortment options, Toronto address, and ordering notice.
-
12 Macarons (Assorted) – Bake Sale Toronto — Bake Sale Toronto
Current flavour descriptions, storage guidance, and product-specific macaron information.
-
Visit Bake Sale Toronto | Six Points, Etobicoke — Bake Sale Toronto
FAQ information about macarons, allergens, customization, ordering notice, pickup, and delivery.
-
Refund policy – Bake Sale Toronto — Bake Sale Toronto
Current pickup, delivery, cancellation, address-change, and product-availability policy details.
About the author
Bake Sale · Company editorial profile
Product information and shopping guidance for Bake Sale customers.