One of my favourite things to bake growing up was chocolate chip cookies. I must have made a batch almost every week. There was something special about pulling warm cookies out of the oven and enjoying one while the chocolate chips were still melted.

When I opened Bake Sale over 20 years ago, I knew cookies had to be part of our everyday lineup.

Over the years, that single chocolate chip cookie has grown into what we now call our Cookie Bar—a collection of classic, made-from-scratch cookies baked the way cookies should be.

We don’t believe you need to reinvent a classic. Our goal has always been simple: make cookies that remind you of the ones your grandmother baked—soft, comforting, generously filled, and impossible to eat just one.

Our Everyday Cookie Bar

Our Cookie Bar features eight delicious flavours:

Chocolate Chip

Our most popular cookie. A soft, chewy cookie packed with plenty of chocolate chips.

Double Chocolate

A rich chocolate cookie loaded with chocolate chips for serious chocolate lovers.

Monster Cookie

A hearty oatmeal cookie made with peanut butter, chocolate chips, and colourful M&Ms.

Funfetti

A buttery vanilla cookie with rainbow sprinkles baked throughout. Fun, nostalgic, and loved by both kids and adults.

Peanut Butter

A classic peanut butter cookie with rich peanut flavour and a soft, chewy texture.

Tuxedo

Can’t decide? Have both. Half Chocolate Chip and half Double Chocolate baked into one delicious cookie.

Oatmeal Raisin

A soft and chewy oatmeal cookie filled with juicy raisins.

Red Velvet

A rich red velvet cookie packed with creamy white chocolate chips.

What Cookie Flavours Do You Have Every Day?

We bake a selection of our Cookie Bar flavours fresh every day.

You’ll almost always find:

• Chocolate Chip
• Double Chocolate
• Funfetti
• Red Velvet

Our Monster, Peanut Butter, Tuxedo, and Oatmeal Raisin cookies rotate regularly, giving you a reason to come back and discover a new favourite.

Can I Order Any Flavour Even If It’s Not in the Store Today?

Absolutely!

If you’re looking for a specific flavour, simply order ahead. We’ll bake any of our Cookie Bar flavours for you—even if it’s not part of that day’s in-store selection.

One of the things our customers love most is that there’s no minimum order. Whether you’d like one cookie for an afternoon treat, a half dozen to take home, or several dozen for a party or office meeting, we’re happy to bake exactly what you need.

Are Your Cookies Soft or Crunchy?

Our cookies are soft and chewy with just the right amount of crispness around the edges. They’re designed to taste like homemade cookies—perfect with a glass of milk, a cup of coffee, or simply on their own.

Are Your Cookies Made From Scratch?

Every single one.

We make all of our cookies from scratch using quality ingredients and real butter. We don’t rely on mixes or shortcuts because we believe you can taste the difference.

Just as importantly, we bake cookies fresh every single day. We don’t keep yesterday’s cookies on the shelf. At the end of the day, any remaining cookies are removed, so when you visit Bake Sale, you can count on enjoying cookies that were baked fresh that day.

It’s one of the reasons our cookies have become a customer favourite for more than 20 years.

Which Cookie Is the Most Popular?

If it’s your first visit, here are a few customer favourites:

• Chocolate Chip – Our bestselling cookie and a classic for a reason.
• Double Chocolate – Perfect for chocolate lovers.
• Funfetti – A favourite with kids and anyone who loves a colourful treat.
• Monster Cookie – Packed with peanut butter, oats, chocolate chips, and M&Ms for lots of flavour and texture.

The truth is, everyone seems to have a favourite—and that’s exactly why we offer such a great variety.

Can I Buy Just One Cookie?

Yes! Whether you’re treating yourself or buying for a crowd, you can purchase as few or as many cookies as you’d like.

How Long Do Your Cookies Stay Fresh?

Our cookies are baked fresh every day, so when you buy them, you’re getting cookies made that day. At home, they’ll stay fresh for several days when stored in an airtight container, and they also freeze beautifully if you’d like to enjoy them later.

Want Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies Anytime?

One of our favourite products is our Bake-at-Home Chocolate Chip Cookies.

We make the cookie dough from scratch, portion it into individual cookies, and freeze them so they’re ready whenever you are.

Simply take out one, two, or as many cookies as you’d like and bake them at home.

Within minutes, your kitchen will be filled with the incredible aroma of freshly baked chocolate chip cookies. Pull them from the oven while they’re still warm and enjoy melted chocolate chips, crisp golden edges, and soft, chewy centres.

It’s the closest thing to homemade without having to measure a single ingredient.

They’re perfect for late-night cravings, after-school treats, unexpected guests, or simply because nothing beats a warm chocolate chip cookie fresh from the oven.

Classic Cookies Never Go Out of Style

For more than 20 years, we’ve been baking cookies the same way we always have—with quality ingredients, classic recipes, and plenty of care.

Whether you’re stopping in for a Chocolate Chip cookie, trying a flavour you’ve never had before, or keeping our Bake-at-Home Chocolate Chip Cookies in your freezer for whenever the craving hits, we hope our cookies become part of your family’s traditions too.

We look forward to welcoming you into Bake Sale and helping you find your new favourite cookie.