Frequently Asked Questions About Our Ice Cream Cakes

What makes Bake Sale ice cream cakes different?

Our ice cream cakes contain a layer of real Bake Sale cake. Instead of choosing between cake and ice cream, you get both in every slice—creamy Kawartha Dairy ice cream, our famous cake, and a delicious buttercream border all together.

What flavours of ice cream cake do you offer?

We offer four flavours: Cookies N’ Cream, Birthday, Moose Tracks, and Death by Chocolate. Each combines Kawartha Dairy ice cream with a layer of real Bake Sale cake, a delicious buttercream border, and fun toppings.

What size are your ice cream cakes?

Each Bake Sale ice cream cake is 8 inches.

How many people does an ice cream cake serve?

Our 8-inch ice cream cakes serve approximately 10 to 12 people.

Do I need to order an ice cream cake in advance?

We recommend ordering ahead whenever possible, especially for weekends, birthdays, and warmer months when ice cream cakes can sell quickly.

Do you keep ice cream cakes in stock for same-day pickup?

We try to keep all four flavours available, but some flavours sell out quickly. You can call the bakery to see what’s currently in stock and have an ice cream cake put aside for you.

Can I add a custom message to my ice cream cake?

Yes! Add a custom message to make your ice cream cake perfect for a birthday or other special celebration.

How should I store my ice cream cake?

Ice cream cakes should be kept frozen until you’re ready to serve them. Place your cake in the freezer as soon as you get home and keep it frozen until shortly before serving.

How long should I leave my ice cream cake out before serving?

Take your ice cream cake out of the freezer and allow it to sit at room temperature for approximately 10 minutes before cutting. This makes it easier to slice while keeping the ice cream cold.

How do I cut an ice cream cake?

For easier slicing, allow your cake to sit at room temperature for approximately 10 minutes. Use a large, sharp knife and run it under hot water before cutting. Wipe the knife between slices and repeat with hot water as needed.

How should I transport an ice cream cake home?

We recommend heading directly home after picking up your ice cream cake and placing it in the freezer as soon as possible. On especially hot days or for longer trips, bringing a cooler or insulated bag can help keep your cake frozen during transportation.

How long can an ice cream cake be out of the freezer?

Because an ice cream cake needs to stay frozen, we recommend keeping it out of the freezer only for the time needed to soften slightly, cut, and serve. Return any leftovers to the freezer promptly.

Do your ice cream cakes contain nuts or other allergens?

Our ice cream cakes contain dairy, wheat, and other allergens depending on the flavour and toppings. Some flavours may contain peanuts or other nuts. If you have an allergy or dietary concern, please contact us before ordering so we can provide more information about the specific cake you’re considering.

Can I order an ice cream cake for delivery?

Yes! Our ice cream cakes are available for delivery through Uber Eats and SkipTheDishes. Because ice cream cakes can only be out of the freezer for a short period of time, we recommend choosing direct delivery when ordering to help ensure your cake arrives as quickly as possible.

Real Cake & Ice Cream in Every Slice

Why choose between cake and ice cream when you can have both?

Our ice cream cakes bring together creamy Kawartha Dairy ice cream, a layer of real Bake Sale cake, a delicious buttercream border, and fun toppings in four delicious flavour combinations.

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, planning a summer get-together, hosting an office celebration, or simply looking for a dessert everyone will love, there’s an ice cream cake waiting for you at Bake Sale Toronto.

Order ahead to make sure your favourite flavour is available, or call us to see what’s in stock today.